Doctor Goodheart's Advice Column - Flirting.com

Ask Doctor Goodheart ... Advice Column

August, 2006

Dear Dr. Goodheart,

I am the type of guy that loves big girls: “more of them to love,” I always say! However, despite my fixation for thicker women, I recently was introduced to this beautiful, charismatic woman who has everything I would want save for her shape, which is thinner than I would prefer. She’s not rail thin, but she is skinny enough to where the idea of her having anything to grab in bed would be a far fetched dream. I know most men would kill to date a woman like this, and I’m not sure why, but I am finding myself filled with reservations. I don’t want to be juvenile but at this point I can’t tell if I’m attracted to her from a mutual respect/platonic standpoint, or if I am sexually attracted to her.

My biggest fear of course is that if I decide to date her, I will suddenly find myself no longer attracted to her, and I don’t want to hurt this nice woman’s feelings. What should I do?

Sincerely,

Wanting More “Junk” (in the trunk),
Albany, NY

Dear Wanting More "Junk",

First off, might I suggest you taking a good look in the mirror and asking yourself, “what is it that truly attracts me to larger women?” Is it their shape, is it their personality (do you naturally gravitate towards larger women with the same personality, etc)? You need to deduce whether or not you are more attracted to larger women because you feel more secure with them than with smaller women who may be seen as generally more attractive (thanks to cultural stereotypes), and thus continually garnering other’s men’s attention.

If you aren’t fully confident in yourself and don’t believe yourself worthy of a good woman you may naturally gravitate towards women who make you feel more secure. That may mean that you may want a larger or less emotionally secure woman rather than a thin and/or confident one, although that’s not to say that skinny girls aren’t insecure and that large women aren’t confident. That’s also not to say larger women don’t need or deserve loving (and good for you for not being blind to their beauty and gifts), all the same, you shouldn’t turn down a perfect woman simply because she’s a little “thin” for your tastes: it would be the same if you were to avoid dating a larger woman simply because of her plus size clothing.

If this woman has everything you desire, besides a few extra pounds around the hips, don’t be an unconfident boob. Give her a fair shot. You just may find that after a few dates you grow more physically and sexually attracted to her for all the right reasons, like her personality! Either way, if you choose not to pursue romantic interests with this woman make sure its for the right reasons and not merely because you wish she filled out her pants a little more in the hind section- and whose not to say that a few months of late-night pizza dates might not assist the problem anyways (pending she’s ok with the weight gain of course).

Best wishes in life, love, and happiness,

Dr. Goodheart / Flirting.com

* * *

Dear Dr. Goodheart,

Recently my girlfriend of three years has been pressuring me to try a threesome. At first she proposed inviting a guy as the third member, but I was adamantly against that since I felt very uncomfortable sharing her sexually with anyone, let alone another man. Even when she offered to invite a woman I felt uncomfortable, although I did feel that, since it was her idea initially, this was the best compromise. However, after our little threesome my girlfriend is hooked. Though we initially did it with one of her good friends, she has since asked me several additional times to have a “round two”, but she is completely indifferent as to whom the girl is. Though I can’t say I completely hated the experience, I can say that I still feel very uncomfortable with the idea since, during the threesome I felt that my girlfriend was more preoccupied with the third party than with satisfying or pleasuring me. I don’t know if it’s just my insecurities bothering me, or my feeling that she isn’t respecting my feelings and treating the relationship with the seriousness and respect that she used to. How do I tell her that I want to curb her lust for threesomes permanently ?

Please help.

Confused but Committed,
Athens, GA

Dear Confused but Committed,

It sounds like your girlfriend is a little confused sexually and may be feeling a little restricted to the confines of her (serious) three-year relationship. Most relationships hit their natural lull (read: low point) within the first 2-3 years. During that time most couples either break up, or, like your girlfriend, decide to try and get innovative in an attempt to put the spice back in life. However, after your girlfriend came up with an idea (which you eventually agreed to) she discovered something which filled a void or provided some sort of substance which she felt was lacking before. The fact that she is seeking to continue this pattern of behavior with the threesomes may be an indication of several things: either she doesn’t feel entirely fulfilled in bed with just the two of you any longer (she’s bored); she may be re-questioning her sexual orientation (based on your argument that she “seems” more into the girl than you during the threesome); or she may feel you two have hit that low point and is looking for a way to bring some spontaneity back into the relationship; or, lastly, she may be acting slightly selfishly and putting a secret desire (to be with women, or engage in threesomes) over your desires to commit and work on your relationship sans a third party.

Whatever the reason, you need to first and foremost sit your girlfriend down and discuss our concerns with her recently randy requests. You also need to clearly convey to her that you aren’t comfortable with a third party and that you desire to work on moving your relationship in the right direction. If she still pushes for threesomes then you need to decide whether or not she’s just being selfish and/or may not be ready for an exclusive heterosexual relationship. She just may be going through a phase and she needs to figure out whether or not she’s willing to risk her relationship with you for a temporary wild spree. If she does seem determined to continue with this lifestyle, it may be time for you to move on and find a woman who will better appreciate your level of commitment (which is a valuable thing these days).n.

Best wishes for love, life, and happiness,

Dr. Goodheart / Flirting.com

* * *

p

Dear Dr. Goodheart,

I am a single, forty-two year-old female who has been engaged three times, but never married, and still a virgin! That’s right, I’m a virgin. The reason all three of my former engagements ended was because I refused to have sex before marriage and, though two of the three men were okay with that arrangement, I realized that my fear of sex was much more than a mere wanting to save my virginity and I was afraid to have sex even after marriage! Instead of seeing it as sacred, I also see it as gross, and I am frequently uncomfortable whenever anyone around me begins to discuss sexual matters openly. I don’t want to end up single the rest of my life but the thought of sex terrifies me and I hate to think that I’m ruining both mine and my partner’s lives because of my phobia. What should I do?

Sincerely,

Virginal Violet
Colorado Springs, CO

Dear Virginal Violet,

Though your case (that being forty-two and a virgin) is rare in today’s society, it’s not entirely unheard of either. However, your preserving your virginity primarily out of fear rather than a moral stance (which I’m assuming your initial intentions were the latter) does signal cause for alarm. It seems that, throughout the years of remaining chaste your “virginal status” has prompted much hype and concern from all those with whom you are closely affiliated. I’m sure your “v” card has become the defining standard by which you are stereotyped; only further provoking your fear of sex. However, as you alluded, sex is not a terrifying thing, but a sacred gift that is to be appreciated and cherished, not feared and disdained.

Since I am not a registered psychologist I cannot offer any official diagnosis, though I’m assuming much of your fear stems from childhood experiences (either trauma, education, upbringing etc.), and has only been reinforced in your adulthood by your being made to continually feel uncomfortable and distinct (not necessarily in a good way) as a virgin. However, that you found two men willing to wait until marriage and that you bailed both times because you were so afraid of sex afterwards is a problem, and yes, it is detrimental to both you and your partner. You are keeping both yourself and your current/future partner(s) from ever being truly happy because of your fear to consecrate a marriage. There’s nothing wrong with waiting: by all means, if you’ve waited this long please continue to do so, however, your reasons for avoiding marriage need to addressed by a professional who may be able to help you gain a new perspective on sex, relationships, life, and yourself in general. Before you enter into another serious engagement, or ditch a current partner, seek professional help and let them open your eyes to all the wonderful possibilities that sex has to offer.

PS: There’s also a lot of great self-help books that deal with this issue as well that can be found at major bookstores if you’re not quite ready to visit a psychologist/psychiatrist.

Best wishes for love, life, and happiness,

Dr. Goodheart / Flirting.com

* * *

Dear Dr. Goodheart,

I have been dating these two guys, quite casually, and very openly now for awhile. Though I enjoy spending time with both (and both know of the other), I must admit that I am torn as to where to take either relationship. Both men are so different and bring completely different pros and cons to the table so whenever I try to decide which one to end and which one to settle down with I find myself stuck. One guy is ready to settle down and get super serious, and he is the type where security would never be an issue, while the other guy is enjoying taking things more slowly and working our way to a stable future. Both seem like the ideal guy, which seems contradictory since they are so different, so now I need help deciding what to do. Please help, Dr. Goodheart !

Sincerely,


Clearly Confused.
Tustin, CA

Dear Clearly Confused,

It sounds like the only one who can help you make a decision is yourself. I think first and foremost you and your heart need to have a little (pardon the pun) “heart-to-heart.” Only you truly know what you want both now and for the future. That you’re so confused about which guy to pick stems from simply having one too many options. I don’t really believe that people have one particular soul mate, though I do believe that people have types and that several potential Mr. Maybes could be “Mr. Right” at any given moment providing the timing is right: the fact that you have found yourself compatible with two entirely different people at the same time only supports the old adage, “timing is everything.” Its likely that you could envision yourself with either one of these guys but the question is which one do you see yourself with right now and which one do you see yourself with in the near and distant future? Hopefully all three answers line up, but when is life ever that easy ?

If you can see yourself with the more casual guy right now, but think Mr. Long-term is perfect for well, long term, then you may want to evaluate what’s most important to you right now for both your life and your potential partner. Are you ready to settle down or no? If yes, you may want to stick things out with commitment guy, if no, you may want to stay casual with the low key partner. Either way, one thing’s for sure: you can’t continue to date both at the same pace without exacerbating your problem. Sooner rather than a later, a decision has to be made.

Best wishes for love, life, and happiness,

Dr. Goodheart / Flirting.com

GO TO: CURRENT MONTH * DOCTOR GOODHEART INDEX * MAIN INDEX

E-Mail ... AskGoodHeart@FLIRTING.com

ChildDevelopment.com * FinancialPlanners.com * NursePractitioners.com